Skip to main content

To Giant Fans: Shut Up And Appreciate Manning


Usually, I don't get into the affairs of other teams and the issues their fan bases face. For the most part, the teams whom I root for and emotionally throw myself into have enough conflicts, dilemmas, and controversy for me to deal with. All you have to do is take a look at the amount of vents and posts yours truly has in the archives of this very blog during those "Isiah" years for my New York Knicks. 

Yet, as a New York Jets fan who continuously hopes each year is the year, or heck, even just a decent year, it bothers me to hear Giants fans lately on the state of their New York Football Giants team, more specifically, Eli Manning.

I'm sure being 0-6 for Giants fans is hard for them to take right now. Once again, I'm a Jets fan, so I'm very familiar with losing during the NFL season. However, the recent majority feedback that is blaming Eli Manning for the team's struggles is baffling. Actually, the continued assault on his character by a select few is downright annoying. 

I'll be the first to admit as a Yankees die hard, there is an overwhelming spoiled nature that has infused the fan base. A fan base so accustomed to winning and good times, it often doesn't appreciate or understand how good they really have it. 

It seems with the recent 0-6 start, Giants fans have adopted that same spoiled nature, but have taken it to another level. 

"Eli Manning has really never been a good QB" 

"This is all on Eli. He looks awful." 

"It might be time to replace this guy [referring to Eli Manning]"

"It's time Reese [referring to Jerry Reese, New York Giants General Manager] begin the search to draft a new QB, or to find a place for Eli to go" 

These were all quotes heard on WFAN, a New York sports radio station. All quotes indicative of a spoiled fan base. All quotes, in my eyes, that simply sound like a bunch of whiny babies. 

The problems facing the Giants are much larger than Eli Manning. For starters, how about that terrible offensive line? The running game, defense, and injuries are some other noteworthy selections if you will. It's not unreasonable to make the statement that Eli Manning is part of the solution more so than the problem. 

I cannot understand how a two-time Super Bowl MVP is being treated like he is. How a quarterback who is as clutch as he is, and has won so many big games for that fan base, is being given a such a hard time. He is possibly the greatest Giants QB of all-time. 



Those are all qualities in a QB many other fan bases across the NFL would love to have. Heck, I've yet to see a consistent Jets quarterback in my lifetime. But I digress. 

I guess my message to Giants fans is this: Shut up, and appreciate what you have, before it's gone. 

Because one day, Manning will be, and you'll regret all of this foolish banter. 

Recently Read

Quick Ponder: My Island Vibes

I would love to have an island, of all the people,  who brought great vibes to my life - past and present.  My island would be amazing. 

Predictions and Wild Guesses for the 2025 MLB Season

Well, after that off-season where the Dodgers deferred enough money to build the Athletics a new ballpark, it's time for the remaining fanbases who don't have Guggenheim money to hope for the best. Even with Opening Day finally here, it's the only time of the year we can actually pretend everyone has a chance, and hope feels, well, somewhat authentic.  White Sox fans, how are we feeling?  As we do every year around these parts, I'm throwing out some predictions and wild guesses for the upcoming MLB 2025 season.  Good luck, White Sox.  --- STANDINGS (WIN) AL EAST  Yankees - 92 Red Sox - 90 Orioles - 88 Rays - 85 Blue Jays - 82 AL CENTRAL Royals - 90 Tigers - 90 Guardians - 88 Twins - 87 White Sox - 65 AL WEST Rangers - 92 Astros - 92 Athletics - 86 Mariners - 85 Angels - 77 NL EAST Phillies - 94 Mets - 92 Braves - 88 Nationals - 78 Marlins - 75 NL CENTRAL Cubs - 88 Brewers - 88 Reds - 87 Pirates - 83 Cardinals - 80 NL WEST Dodgers - 96 Diamondbacks - 90 Padres - ...

Quick Ponder: Future Self

We always think,  what would we say  to our  younger self? However,  what would  our younger self say  if they met us, today?