Skip to main content

Thoughts on the 2020 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot


Derek Jeter is now in the Hall of Fame.

The thought is rather incredible to me that I've not only seen the entire storied career of this great shortstop and athlete, but now will watch him go into the Hall of Fame. 

I can remember ALL of his highlights. All of the replays and images that are now replaying before my eyes, ripping open thoughts and memories of places, times, and feelings which ran parallel alongside my own life's developments. 

All of them, along with the soundtracks of play calls and my own reactions in the moment, then, can easily be recited word for word and reenacted move for move, raising goosebumps on my arms, and cracking a smirk on my face.

What's even crazier? 

Is that I sit here typing this post wondering how I will describe Derek Jeter to my son one day. And of course, pondering about the future Yankee who will come along in his lifetime that he'll be able to grow alongside with. 

That's what Jeter means to me - consistency and greatness. And even after 20 +years, it's still hard to believe that it's been this long. That his career has been there this whole entire time - year in, and year out. 

And while I romanticize about Jeter, there is also Larry Walker. 

As Walker jokingly (and accurately) put it on his MLB Network interview, he's the B-Side on a record, in which the hit single is featured on the A-Side. 

Despite the hilariously humbling joke, Walker represents everything that is the growth of baseball. A Canadian learning the game. A dude that simply mashed every step of the way, and now, can give legitimacy to what was once an industry-wide career handicap in terms of legacy and forever, in that of Coors Field. 

Here are some other quick thoughts on this year's Hall of Fame Ballot: 

99.7% - NOT UNANIMOUS

For the record, these were my final thoughts from last year's Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot:
And finally...
With the "unanimous" seal broken, what are the chances Derek Jeter doesn't become the second person in 2020?
Of course, it only takes one guy...only one.
It's unfortunate that this will somehow become attached to Jeter's induction. One person - ONE! PERSON! - decided to not vote for Derek Jeter to become a member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame. ONE! SINGLE! CLOWN OF A PERSON! 

But I digress...

After all, the history of these things rendered the likes of so many greats who fell short in attaining 100% approval for the Hall of Fame. Griffey. Ripken. Gwynn. Maddux. Just to name a few in modern times. All who should have been recent no-doubters, in fact had voters who doubted the relevance of their ability. 

But then again, Jackie Robinson got into the HOF on 77% of the vote. Think about THAT one. 

Regardless, Jeets is going where he deserves to be, and that is all that matters. 

NEXT UNANIMOUS?

By the way, I believe the next player to have a real shot at earning a unanimous vote is that of Ichiro Suzuki. We'll see in about five years.

CURT'S GOT NEXT

Coming in at just over 70% is Curt Schilling on this ballot. And if projections, educated guesses, and recent voting (Mike Mussina?) serve as a foreshadow for 2021, Schilling should be on his way in next year. 

While Schilling is well...ummm, a special kind of a human being when it comes to his personality, his politics, and his investments, as a baseball player, I really believe he is a Hall of Famer. 

Can't wait to hear about the damn bloody sock lore next year. And yes, that was super sarcasm. 

BONDS AND CLEMENS

So, what's the deal here, collectively? Are we making them both sweat it out until the final year? And if that's the case, having them both go in together surely is going to make for an interesting induction ceremony. 

Of course, if this is the plan. 

And one more thing, as we now enter the age of technology cheating, if we're evaluating the PED era for the HOF, David Ortiz's support should be interesting once he gets on the ballot. 

THANKING LARRY

Todd Helton is going to definitely benefit from this new found pivoting away from the utterly stupid unfortunate stigma that is players who played a large amount of time at Coors Field not being taken seriously. 

Larry Walker's induction helps in a great way here. 


GOLDEN GLOVES

With each passing year, the more it looks like a path is being cleared for Omar Vizquel and Scott Rolen to make a run at immortality. 

However, I'm still torn on them being super great, and whether they surpass that threshold into the really elite. 

GARY FREAKIN' SHEFFIELD

Speaking of making decisions on the elite, am I the only one who finds the case for Gary Sheffield not getting enough publicity? I'm not saying he's a definite, but Sheffield, in my opinion (of course), is closer than Vizquel and Rolen, no? Seriously, everyone, dig into Sheff's career. He's very underrated. 

And finally...

NO RESPECT

Why no love for Jeff Kent? Like, for real? 

We have Brad Penny and Raul Ibanez out here receiving Hall of Fame votes, and Jeff Kent is struggling to crack 30%. 

J.J. Putz got a vote! J.J. Putz! 

We've gotten to a point in sports wherever everyone wants to be the smartest person in the room to go against the grain. Have we lost our ability to simply just watch and appreciate greatness - and call it is as such? 

Recently Read

Would You Rather: Questions 121-130

This edition of "Would You Rather" is credited to the NBA Would You Rather NBA Account on Instagram ( See Here ). Adding to the fun, this edition (and possibly future ones) are all NBA basketball questions.  121. Who would you rather have on your favorite NBA team - Giannis Antetokounpo or James Harden?  Seeing how I'm a lifelong suffering Knicks fan, the thought of any of these guys in blue and orange is hard to believe. With that said, I'm taking the Greek Freak for this reason - I enjoy watching him play a bit more. Nothing against Harden who is amazing as well, but at times, the ball sticks and that isn't always fun. Plus, I feel like we haven't yet seen a finished Giannis. 122. Would you rather have Giannis Antetokounpo with no driving ability or James Harden with no Three-Point shooting ability?  This is definitely a weird and unique one, but I'll take Harden. Giannis without his strength doesn't offer much. However, if Harden's d...

The Pondering 10 - Favorite Knicks Head Coaches

I'm still on a championship high (probably until Banner night in October to be honest), so I'm dropping more Pondering 10s as my brain (and heart) works through all of the emotions and reflection from my beloved New York Knicks - 2025-2026 NBA Champions!  Let's talk coaches.  We've been through so many. My fellow Knicks fans, we've seen so many coaches walk the sidelines of Madison Square Garden, and the recent championship is so amazing to think about - Mike Brown, one year, title.  With that said, here is a list of my favorite Knicks Coaches (in my lifetime, so no Red Holtzman). It's tougher than you think, but we're doing it.  To begin, here are those banned from this list. On the sheer qualifier that these coaches - by fault of their own, or maybe not - will always resonate with disdain and the lowest of the lows.  Derek Fisher Oh, the Phil Jackson era. When we were given a coach who had never done so before, implementing the triangle offense was more im...

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 6/21/26

The Sunday Sundown Rundown (formerly in the format of "3 Up and 3 Down") is where I share thoughts on three topics that piqued my interest, along with my favorite photo from the week. Knicks Parade  I'm sure you can tell from the recent posts on this here site, I am still in the Knicks Championship thought.  NBA Champs, babbyyyyyyyyyyyy!! Nonetheless, the parade was everything any Knicks fan (new, old, and long-time suffering) could have imagined. Memorable scenes. Emotional. And unforgettable.  For me, it was Mayor Mahdani's speech that jogged us down memory lane, and more so, the visual of the NBA Cup Trophy, the Eastern Conference Trophy (Bob Cousy Trophy), and dear (elusive) Larry O'Brien sitting on a table in the NYC sun. We ran the table.  Beauftiful. UK Social Media Ban This is interesting to me. The recent ban in the UK on social media use for individuals under 16 is well...yeah, interesting. There are continued heaps of data that show the dangers of soci...