Skip to main content

It's Time. Pete Rose Belongs in the Hall of Fame

It sounds mean, but Pete Rose served his lifetime ban.

After the recent passing of the all-time hits leader, the court of public opinion is now in session on one of the sport's biggest questions and most debated topics - should Pete Rose be in the Hall of Fame?

We all know the stances and varied degrees of opinion on this by now. Rose committed the biggest and most unforgivable crime in the game (and in all sports) - gambling not just on the game, but on your own team. That’s sanctimonious to the integrity of everything that is MLB. 

And there is the other side - watching baseball evolve into a product that pushes gambling on billboards, commercials, and a staple of the fan experience, yet, retrospectively keeping one of the sport's most salient record holders guilty for the same thing that is now exercised heavily.

The Hall of Fame of Fame standards have been criticized as we deal with the aftermath of the steroid era and the other major elephant on the field - Barry Bonds being left out of Cooperstown as well for a sin that carried blame among many others. A sport built on tradition, records, and numbers, with the two most important records of hits and home runs not being included in official recognition does integral harm in linking past, present, and future. Again, that thread is what makes baseball such a beautiful thing. 

Surely, in a posthumous world without Rose, many are filled with emotion and erring on the latter - baseball needs to readjust to the ethics it has moved the goalposts on.

However, the discussion may be for discussion's sake, something we've become too accustomed to in today's sports landscape. Rose outright served his lifetime ban. While involved in fringe parts of the game with broadcasts or the occasional "analyst" role, he never got closer to the game in a impactful manner. He was never reinstated in baseball. He truly did serve his due.

At this point, the past cannot be changed. And for some who believe the ban should have been corrected or changed, it's a moot point.

It’s time. 

It’s time to place Rose where he belongs in the Hall of Fame. And while he cannot see his day in Cooperstown, we can all agree that maybe - just maybe - the right (and agreeable) thing to do is indeed before us. 

The fulfillment of his punishment for an unforgivable crime in the game has been paid. A celebration of his contributions to the sport and honoring his legacy - with the complexity that it was and is - is necessary for the Rose family and for the history and ethical fabric of the game.

It’s time. He has served his punishment. Pete Rose belongs in the Hall of Fame.

Recently Read

Quick Ponder: Future Self

We always think,  what would we say  to our  younger self? However,  what would  our younger self say  if they met us, today?

Knicks Trauma - Ugh Not Again

Well, that was a kick in the stomach.  Coming off a week where the word "catharsis" was used as the description for the euphoria and release of joy from two and a half decades of suffering, Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals against the Indiana Pacers brought about another word - trauma.  Watching the Knicks collapse was the kind of moments that come with these deep runs and moments. NBA Playoff basketball will do that. Yet, this loss - this one - feels about as bad as the 2004 ALCS when the Yankees collapsed in the series to the Boston Red Sox.  That one carries some serious trauma. Luckily, the series isn't over.  Some other quick thoughts from this awful, awful night, New York Knicks Basketball.  - Not to conjure up hyperbole, or even contribute to "hot take" sports reaction culture - but this might have been the worst loss in Knicks franchise history. I cannot think of another in my lifetime, or historically.  - Tyrese Haliburton's "choke"...

Knicks Back in ECF Causing Catharsis

I've certainly shared my emotions and thoughts regarding the New York Knicks on this site over the years. There have been plenty of those to sort through - most of them are rants. Tonight, the New York Knicks ultimately destroyed the Boston Celtics in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference Semi-Finals, 119-81. I sat on my couch, afraid to allow myself to feel joy until that final buzzer. As a Knicks fan, I've been through too much to allow myself to do anything else, to make any assumption, until it was final. Until it was confirmed. Until something couldn't fall through...the way we're used to.  Once it was final, it was unreal.  The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference Finals. For the first time since 2000.  I was 15 years old the last time that happened. And that was a run with a squad that I consider (still) to be my favorite Knicks team of all-time.  I sat on my couch with all sorts of feelings. My wife was likely trying to understand the moment. My son, exci...