Skip to main content

Carmelo Anthony's Moment of Truth?


I wonder what Carmelo Anthony is thinking?

It must be tough for him to sit at home and watch these former Knicks play on the game's biggest stage, the stage he has yet to reach, a stage many didn't think was possible, especially when those "pieces" that surrounded him as the centerpiece of the New York Knickerbockers are now household names. 

"The Knicks let these guys go?"
"These guys play so much better with LeBron than they ever did with Melo"

I've made it quite known already that Alex Rodriguez is the most fascinating athlete in my lifetime - at least for me, anyways. Check the DP Page of Fame to see that. Regardless, there is something about Carmelo Anthony that is headed in that same direction. Fascinating? Not really. But, frustrating? Absolutely! 

I'll be honest, I'm lukewarm on Anthony. Always have been. He seemed like a terrific player from afar with the Denver Nuggets. However, sometimes the ESPN/media hype and the unabashed (and often fickle and reactive) rhetoric from the talking heads make you believe in it all. Highlights can do that. Until I saw Anthony play every night (#KnicksState: Part 3 - Identifying Carmelo Anthony)

Don't get me wrong, the guy is amazing. Unbelievable scorer. Tremendous talent. Heck, the night he scored a franchise record of 62 points on the then Charlotte Bobcats is still one of my favorite moments in Knicks lore (Carmelo's 62 Will Always Be Ours). 

Yet, watching him every night, that air in that hype balloon was let out quickly. There is just something about Carmelo Anthony overall that is frustrating. Whether it is the poor shot selection, the lack of leadership that is evident time and time, and time again, or for me, things like him playing in the meaningless All-Star Game and delaying his recuperation and comeback for next season (so selfish), I've soured on his "star". 

And let's not forget his constant diatribe of reminding us all of "how close he was to signing with the Chicago Bulls" during this past summer of free agency. Enough already, dude. We get it. You're here, so, you know, act like it and move on. 

But with all of that said, one has to think Anthony is a bit chapped about this time, no? Guys he couldn't get it done with - Iman Shumpert and J.R. Smith - are now in the NBA Finals. They aren't playing any better than they were when they were Knicks. Just somehow, LeBron James' unbelievable leadership (in my opinion, his greatest attribute) was able to galvanize these guys into a TEAM buy-in and belief, something he has yet to do with the New York Knicks in four years. And sadly, sometimes even with a better roster. 

No, this post isn't about beating up on Anthony. It just seems like the the Carmelo Anthony star has fallen more than it has ever had, and this Finals is further exposing it to depths we've never seen before. 

I'm just hoping that this is the final motivating factor for Anthony. Enough excuses. Enough cliche rhetoric. Enough with "building your brand" and focusing on outside projects. This year, and this NBA Finals is the final gauntlet thrown down before Anthony. Are you interested in winning or not? 

It's really a weird moment of truth for Camelo Anthony's career, without him actually, you know, playing. 

No, he isn't LeBron James, and he shouldn't be compared to him. No one is. James is in another world and is so damn good, it isn't even describable. However, Carmelo Anthony is a really, really good player and that's about it. And for a guy of his potential and overall ability when he truly locks in, really, really good is coming up tremendously short. 

Despite it all, there is a part of me that still holds out hope for Melo. Honestly, I still believe someone else needs to come here and be the Batman to Melo's Robin. Whether that's a free agent, our "disappointing" 4th round pick (depending on your outlook), or simply an aging veteran who can take care of the intangibles, I'm not completely closing the book on Anthony yet. 

Again, if we can only get into the mind of Carmelo Anthony as he watches these NBA Finals, we would know the overwhelming truth about him. For now, he remains overwhelmingly frustrating to this Knicks fan, and for all Knicks fan alike. 

Recently Read Posts

Impact No Surrender 2023 Review: "Interested in where the Product is Going"

I've fallen behind on my Impact Wrestling viewing, but honestly, that's okay. For viewership and enjoyment, yes. Not so well for posting a review for readership long after it's noteworthy or relevant. But whatevs, that's just where I am in life. Wrestling is much more fun removed from the restraints and influence of the criticism and impact (no pun intended) of the current time. That's just me. You can probably thank social media. Moving on, No Surrender 2023 continues Impact's progress into the new year. The product is still solid and consistent with a nice blend of characters and wrestlers moving in and out of the main event scene, along with a fresh batch of a resurgence of characters and occurrences. Nothing says that more than Rich Swann vs. Josh Alexander.  No Surrender was a solid event, but it does leave me extremely interested in where the product is going, or should I say planning, for 2023. I don't want to say that Alexander's title reign has

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 2/19/23

3 Up 1. India's Tap Water Access - This is a rather remarkable story. It's a story that offers humility wrapped in the extraordinary. India's Jal Jeevan Mission provided almost 79 million - 79 MILLION! - households with tap water. Just tap water!  2. Jordan Make-A-Wish Record - MJ is often loved through nostalgia, narrative, and remembrance for being politically neutral - even in giving. MJ these days has made some influential contributions, including this latest $10M donation to the Make-A-Wish foundation.  3. WWE Elimination Chamber - A tremendously entertaining pay-per-view on the road to Wrestlemania. The best storyline in pro wrestling continues to evolve between Sami Zayn and the Bloodline.  3A. City of Montreal - Give it up to the city of Montreal for what made a few nights of pro wrestling an awesome experience. Can we get this city more events?  3 Down 1. Michigan State Shooting - We're broken. Very broken. My thoughts and prayers are with those friends and fam

A Product of Us: Thoughts on Durant Trade

I said back in July when Kevin Durant rocked the NBA world with his trade request, that he "showed us who he was".  It wasn't a negative comment, but one that encompasses his entire career being a product of our current sport climate - success and focus on legacy. We emphasize the value of a career on rings, and thus, Durant has too. Why wouldn't he?!  Upon waking up and realizing that Durant will don the purple and orange for the Phoenix Suns in what is clearly now a team to watch come the NBA Playoffs, I find myself further pondering if Kevin Durant is the prime result of what we - yes, us! - have done to the modern athlete.  Today, Durant is one of the greatest basketball players I've ever seen. EVER. The dude is rare. He's a seven-foot magician which makes defending him even more difficult based on how damn efficient he is on the basketball court. It's downright poetic and beautiful to watch Durant play. And yes, I'm romanticizing his game. I belie

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 1/8/22

3 Up 1. New Year - Happy New Year to you all! I've written it in a bunch of emails, mainly to be courteous, but I really do wish you the best for you. I hope 2023 is a great one for all of you DP readers.  2. Buffalo Athletic Trainers - Let's give it up for the Athletic Trainers of the Buffalo Bills who performed with courage, steadfastness, and urgency in regard to Damar Hamlin. We should be celebrating those trainers more.  2A. Athletic Trainers - And because I'm always around them, let's give it up for Athletic Trainers in general. They do so much and very much go unnoticed in the space of sports, athletics, and performance.  2B. Damar Hamlin - Praying for Hamlin and his family... 3. Broadway Bounceback - We all like to believe we're back from COVID, but we're not. But it's news like Broadway having its biggest week of sales since the pandemic began is some nice news. Everyone in the theatre industry deserves it.  3 Down 1. Damar Hamlin Situation - Horri