Skip to main content

Correcting a Wrong Needs Truth: More Needed As MLB Adds Negro Leagues to History Books

The announcement by Major league Baseball of the addition, and overdue recognition of the Negro Leagues to their record books, shocked me. Throughout my entire life - a devoted fan and lover of the game of baseball - I've always had to learn about the Negro Leagues under my own accord. A deep dive that often requires research that involves reading old newspaper headlines, listening to podcasts of Negro League ballplayers, and lining up the true history of the game with that of what is readily available and pushed through the MLB lens. 

The fact of the matter is, much of the experience mirrors heavily what black history is in this very country. Separated, and needed to be sought. Often, never talked about to hide or prevent the complete truth in fear of facing the biggest reckoning yet to be dealt with within our nation - racism. 

Yes, that is heavy. But again, there is no way around talking about this latest development without laying down some thick and hard-to-hear rhetoric. 

It rides on the same track lines of describing Jackie Robinson as "breaking the colored barrier", a much easier, hallow way of describing what Jackie's accomplishment really was, being the first black player that the all-white-MLB allowed to play within their league. So yeah, it's not as triumphant and rosy as the "breaking the color barrier" narrative seems or attempts to carry. 

Then again, breaking "the color barrier" is such a stupid description. 

The latest merging carries a whole helluva lot of baggage far exceeding the acknowledgment of many great black baseball players beyond Jackie and Hank Aaron. Both of whom are on record as stating there were better ballplayers than them in the Negro Leagues. 

Jackie and the Hammer were great - actually, amazing. There is no disputing that. But enduring and progressing was their best attribute and greatest offering to the game. And there were so many others who never were granted that stage - because again, MLB wouldn't let them. Let's repeat that - MLB would not let black players play on their fields. That's the truth, here. 

Again, that's what this is about. And that is the ugly truth at the core of this matter. Tabbing "injustices" with no ownership and using phrases such as "elevated" are just more recent "broke the color barrier" phrases. 

However, it's a start. Though,  I'm not sure I completely agree with merging the record books. 

The Negro Leagues is an example of black excellence in America that embodies independent innovation and entrepreneurship. The kind of "separate but equal" that - let's call it what it is - drives bigoted white powerful people crazy. 

In all forms of life, within black culture, the Negro Leagues is used as the example of what can be accomplished when doors are closed and yes, you are not allowed to participate...or the color barrier wasn't broken as of yet. See it doesn't make sense, does it?

Nonetheless, Black individuals created their own. Established their own. Developed their own. And quite frankly, it is the rarest case within spectrums of our society where that black entity far exceeded the product with the resources within that separate but equal culture/oppressive system. 

We gon' start a society within a society,

That's Major, just like the Negro Leagues.

Jay-Z, Legacy

So much of what we see as normal within modern-day baseball and it's operations, were created and founded within the Negro Leagues (i.e. the establishment of night games, in-game entertainment, free agency, and more...). 

It also helps the legend grow for some of our already-known MLB legends. As you seek out Negro League history, you learn of Babe Ruth's constant barnstorming with them, to get better, and that he even advocated for integration

So yeah, wayyyyy more props to the Babe. 

There is also a particular reverence that surrounds the Negro Leagues because it thrived on its own. And historians will tell you - even the first-hand witnesses such as Jackie and Hank - that the Negro Leagues rivaled MLB in regards to talent and competitive ability. There is no need to "elevate" anyone in this merger.

So while yes, I am very happy for hundreds of black baseball players who will be discovered by historians and fans for their greatness, as well as the many families who will reap the joy of generational excellence gone far too long unrecognized. I'm looking forward to that. But I'll miss that special pride that Negro Leaguers had in knowing they didn't need MLB. 

Of course, there will be the loud uncomfortableness of many who will hold on to what they already know and stubbornly refuse this "change" in their constant "leave the game alone" stance. Their sudden uneasiness expressed via unwritten rule no. 8321 that the purity of the game is being ripped apart at its seams because I won't understand it, will be another round of baseball's much-needed evolution. That should be fun messy annoying interesting. 

With all of that said, I sense merging the books will tarnish that shiny footnote of excellence in our history books - American history. The one that has always been used as an example for oppressed people to go ahead and make one bigger, better, so much so, that they'll need you

But also, my biggest fear is that many years from now, new historians and fans will look in the books, and that presence of pain and triumph that the Negro Leagues represented will not be there, covered by a false sense of the journey of the past. 

Yet, even with a merged history book, it still doesn't exercise the guilt baseball has long carried. or the way it has treated black stakeholders of the game for the duration of its existence.

Because, quite frankly - this right here - is the baseball version of reparations. All of it. The entire thing. Baseball is looking to make this right. I can't knock that at all. Much like the existence of the Negro Leagues served as a microcosm of society, baseball once again is holding a mirror on the mess and the uncomfortableness needed to make things right in our country regarding race and inequality. 

For a sport so diverse, MLB and its culture have long carried the flag for appeasing white audiences with emphasized white mythical heroes; an emphasis on maintaining the status quo for "purity of the game"; a deeply rooted inability to mass-market star athletes; an unconditional attachment to it's "unwritten rules" (Did you know: established to make the Negro Leagues seem "uncivilized and unorganized"), and failing attempts to correct declining black participation in the sport.

Even after Jackie, you know, got by that color barrier hurdle in 1947, there were still teams that were not integrated until 1959. Further proof of how slow baseball's acceptance of the color barrier-breaking really was, and just another example of baseball's inability to evolve past its own demons. 

But again, I give MLB tons of credit here. It is trying to make things right, following a year where so many were forced to reflect on historical decisions and implications. And for a sport that is historically entrenched and leans itself to a crowd not interested in some of the "messaging" that happened on fields this summer, I respect the stance. Because this is not easy. And it won't be. And, it shouldn't be. 

But, I am excited about it. 

Welcoming the Negro Leagues is a great first thought. But, just like society, the best way to start this process is by acknowledging the truth. The real truth. Nothing changes until you wrestle with that. 

Color barriers weren't "broken". Black players weren't allowed until you deemed they could hang. They weren't seen as equals - not just on the field, but as men. You are now getting around to acknowledging that. 

So MLB, Commissioner Manfred, avid fans of Ty Cobb, and those who post your annual #jackierobinsonday photos on social media,  I've taken the time to re-do this new campaign. Here is your initial letter to your fan base:

Dear Negro League Ball Players, 

Our bad, we didn't let you play. We were wrong. We lead, we were participatory, and we were silent in that injustice against you for so long. You were more than worthy. And we see that now. We see you. Our records going forward will reflect that. 

Love,

Major League Baseball

Recently Read Posts

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 10/10/21

3 Up 1. Moderna Vaccine to Low Income Nations - In a world where the idea of "pandemic" now feels like a state of mind or the privilege of belief, Moderna has decided to aim its efforts in getting at least 1 billion doses to low-income countries the COVID vaccine. I'll save the "vaccine" chat for another time - but this is pretty awesome by Moderna. And oh yeah, highly needed.  2. Candace Parker and Diana Taurasi - Two absolute legends of the WNBA had some legacy-cementing moments this week. Parker lead her hometown Chicago Sky into the WNBA finals, and Taurasi, was named the GOAT of the WNBA by fans. Because well, she is. Congrats to both.  3. Netlfix's On My Block - For the second week in a row I'm putting a personal - and admittedly, biased - selection in the "Up" section. One of my favorite shows by Netflix, On My Block , released its fourth and final season, and yes, I binged it on my daily commute home. Gonna miss the crew from Freeridge.

CM Punk's Return - Perfect Timing for the Symbol of Anti-WWE

Looooooooook in my eyes, what do you see?! The lyrics to Cult of Personality, especially that first bar,  never felt so fitting for CM Punk as it did last night.  For the most part, everything that is CM Punk's return to wrestling last night at AEW Rampage ties directly into my latest thoughts on pro wrestling - the company is making it must-see destination television, an element desperately needed from pro wrestling.  Last night was incredible as again, it was another moment that made wrestling feel alive - with a wild and energetic pulse. It was one of the coolest moments in pro wrestling that you knew was coming, expected, anticipated, and it was everything and more. Again, MUST-SEE television. That's hard to do.  For me, it wasn't just Punk's return to pro wrestling, but the mere presence and voice of his inclusion in today's space. We know that Punk can deliver on the microphone - probably his best and most signature attribute. We also know that yes, he can

The Pondering 10 - Yankees Fandom Annoyance

I'm a New York Yankees fan. If you haven't gotten that already from this blog, then the surprise declaration gives you a small set up for this latest Pondering 10 post. Yes, the Yankees are having a challenging year, and there are so many discussions and breakdowns that can be had that are productive, beneficial, and enlightening to why this season is unfolding the way it is.  You know what is not helpful? Yankee fans antics. Ironic, huh? I've long since realized that I'm associated with this fan base than can be overbearing and at times, super annoying. However, none more so than this year. Listening to sports radio, Yankees Twitter, and talking-head television has made that more clear than ever before.  With that said, here is my Pondering 10 on my Yankees Fandom Annoyance:

Shoulda, Woulda - Ehhh: Thoughts on the Ending to the 2021 Yankees Season

I've waited to write this post. After all, it's been a tremendously emotional season...well, for the fan base that is.  For me, everything about this year's Yankees playoff run - or exit - was expected. This team, was as complex and complicated of a team as we've seen in a long time. Bad? No, I wouldn't say that. And I know that may trigger some in the fan base - but bad teams just don't make the playoffs in baseball. However, this team was incredibly flawed - to a glaring fault. Rooted deep, deep, deep in a philosophy that currently drives the organization and has now proven to be fruitless - and even more so year after year.  So no, I never expected this team to do much other than possibly surprise me with a deep playoff run. We've seen glimpses of this team's conflicting identity by running the bases, moving runners, getting timely hits, and looking somewhat threatening to the rest of the league. And yet, we've seen this team play terrible defense