Skip to main content

Would You Rather: Questions 171-180


After a few fun editions of the Would You Rather series that focused on the NBA, I take a swing (ah ha!) at some questions geared toward Major League Baseball. Enjoy! 

171. Would you rather have Tatis, Soto, or Acuna for the next ten years? 

This might be one of the easiest questions in this entire ordeal. Why? Because this is a can't lose!! Regardless, while I love Acuna (major save-face preface) and Soto is unreal (another one), I'm going with Fernando Tatis Jr., the coolest player in baseball at the publishing of this post. 

172. Would rather have Beiber, Cole, or deGrom pitch a must-win game? 

deGrom then. deGrom now. deGrom forever. 

Miss me with the hate if you think I should go with Cole as a Yankees fan.

173. Would you rather have the duo of Freeman and Acuna, Betts and Bellinger, or Trout and Rendon?

Oooooooooh, now this is a VERY tough question! I typically go Trout-anything because well, he's Mike Trout. However, I'm going with Freeman and Acuna. Without diving into numbers while giving my instant reaction (party of the essence of this series, no?), I think they're the best combo of the bunch. Freeman never gets love. 

174. Would you rather Shohei the pitcher or Shohei the hitter? 

Both. The dude is a human video game create-a-player. I just appreciate all of it. 

But seriously, I'll go with Shohei the hitter. 

175. Would you rather throw a no-hitter or hit 4-home runs in a game? 

Early 20s me as a pitcher would say, easily, the no-hitter. 

Late 30s me as a softball player says, no noubt, the 4-home run game. 

In my heart of hearts - give me the no-no. 

176. Would you rather be a yearly post-season contender with a chance to win it all, or a guaranteed one-time World Series winner and no post-season appearances for the next ten years?

You always need to put yourself in a position to win. That's sports. You can also grab multiple depending on what breaks right for you. 

177. Would you rather throw a no-hitter in your hometown or home ballpark? 

My only NCAA win came on the ground of Brooklyn, NY - my hometown. That was cool. That felt extra special. Give me the hometown no-no. 

178. Would you rather more offense in the game or more pitching? 

Can I say more action, overall? 

But for the sake of the question - more offense (not necessarily of the home run kind). 

179. Would you rather see the Athletics or Rays relocate? 

Ugh - I don't want to relocate either out of the area.  

First, please don't rip the A's away from Oakland! They've already lost the Warriors (across the bay to San Francisco), the Raiders (to Las Vegas) and in some stretches, the 49ers, who moved down to San Jose. 

Keep the A's in Oakland in a new building. 

And here's my answer, relocate the Rays to Ybor City (still in Tampa). Get Tampa out of St. Petersburg and the hell that is traffic to that location.

180. Would you rather hit a walk-off home run or end the game striking out the hitter looking?

Again...

Early 20s me that came out of the bullpen - I want to end the game striking out the hitter. 

Late 30s me wants the walk-off softball hit. 

Deep down, yeaaaaahhhhh...I want the strikeout.

Recently Read

Would You Rather: Questions 121-130

This edition of "Would You Rather" is credited to the NBA Would You Rather NBA Account on Instagram ( See Here ). Adding to the fun, this edition (and possibly future ones) are all NBA basketball questions.  121. Who would you rather have on your favorite NBA team - Giannis Antetokounpo or James Harden?  Seeing how I'm a lifelong suffering Knicks fan, the thought of any of these guys in blue and orange is hard to believe. With that said, I'm taking the Greek Freak for this reason - I enjoy watching him play a bit more. Nothing against Harden who is amazing as well, but at times, the ball sticks and that isn't always fun. Plus, I feel like we haven't yet seen a finished Giannis. 122. Would you rather have Giannis Antetokounpo with no driving ability or James Harden with no Three-Point shooting ability?  This is definitely a weird and unique one, but I'll take Harden. Giannis without his strength doesn't offer much. However, if Harden's d...

Quick Ponder: No Matter What

"You can give  everything to something, and no matter what, it is always gonna do what it's gonna do." I feel that these days. I get it. 

The Pondering 10: 2026 NBA All-Star Weekend

Contrary to the discourse that always surrounds the NBA All-Star Weekend, I genuinely enjoyed the weekend, and even more so, the All-Star Game. No, for real. All love here.  Although the Dunk Contest really is on its last legs. That was tough to watch.  Nonetheless, I'm keeping it all good vibes on this one as a fan. Just a quick Pondering 10 on my favorite things from the 2026 NBA All-Star Weekend.  --- View this post on Instagram A post shared by New York Knicks 🏀 (@nyknicks) 10. JB vs. KAT Moment Big Knicks homer moment here. If you frequent these parts, you already know that. Watching the Captain go at KAT brought a moment of joy for all of us in Knicks fandom. Neither one came away with anything. I'm just glad they're in perfect health as we head toward the second half of the season with the Playoffs looming.  9. VJ Edgecomb Wins Rising Stars MVP It's a tough admit for me. Because, I already enjoy Tyrese Maxey's game so much. Now, another ...