Skip to main content

Dome Pondering Movie Review: Moneyball (2011)

What is it about?

Oakland A's General Manager, Billy Beane, utilizes a new way of analyzing performance in baseball to field an affordable and successful team.

Who is in it? 

Brad Pitt - Billy Beane

Jonah Hill - Peter Brand

Phillip Seymour Hoffman - Art Howe

Favorite Scene: 

During an organizational meeting, Billy Beane confronts his scouts about attempting to solve the problems the team is facing during the off-season. While the scouts see the problem as filling the void of departing players, Beane sees the problem of something much greater.

Favorite Quote: 

Billy Beane: [Suggesting a player for first base] Scott Hatteberg.
Scout Barry: Who?
Billy Beane: Exactly. The guy sounds like an Oakland A already.
---
Billy Beane: When you get the answer you want, hang up.

Review:

Moneyball is a film that has been acclaimed by many and has been nominated for various Academy Awards. While the acting and cinematography of Moneyball gives it that Academy deserving feel, the true essence of what made the concept intriguing is missing. 

The success rate of popular books being turned into blockbuster moves has been very low. Unfortunately, Moneyball is another example of this. The film lacks a true feel of presenting the true theory of the moneyball system and how it changed performance evaluation in baseball. It gives viewers a misconstrued view and leaves those not aware of the system very lost. Instead, it focused on Billy Beane, and depicted the Oakland A's as some type of Bad News Bears-like franchise of Major League Baseball. Because of this, the film never gets out of first gear, and is presented in such a simple, non-exciting way that lacks any type of depth. 

All in all, the film simply does not do the book the type of justice it deserves. And despite the expectation of not surpassing the book in experience, Moneyball the film still falls flat.

Other than a fantastic performance by Brad Pitt who was so good, he seemed as if he was a Billy Beane clone, this one is not worth the hype. If you're a die hard baseball fan check it out, otherwise, wait for a cold and rainy day to watch this to kill some time. 

Grade: 2.5/5

Recent Favorites

Quick Ponder: Daily Armor

Imagine, if we can see the dents and scratches, the smashes and chaos,  on the daily armor, each of us put on. Just imagine. 

2024 NBA All-Star Weekend Thoughts

There's something wrong with the All-Star Game.  Yeah, we've definitely had this conversation before. Expect to pick up this very discussion (again) in July when Major League Baseball has their version in the "Mid-Summer Classic" when it is the ONLY current topic to bounce around in the stratosphere of sports discourse.  What's wrong with the All-Star Game?!  I'm not dismissing the obvious - yes, the NBA All-Star Game is very much at an alarming point of necessary refinement and change - evaluation is needed. What we saw on Sunday night was not disappointing, but outright embarrassing. Also yes, gone are the days when the game flooded your television screen at a respectable 6:30pm on NBC, and you were wowed by the athleticism and star power of the first half of the game, and treated to what felt like the world's best players playing pickup basketball on the grandest stage.  Now? Not so much. So yeah, we got the message. The outrage - and shock TV and hot t

Dome Pondering Movie Review: Hustle (2022)

What is it about? A long-time scout, Stanley Sugarman, grinds out the life of an NBA scout and the politics of the NBA by taking a chance on a prospect he believes in to change both of their lives.  Who is in it? Adam Sandler - Stanley Sugarman Juancho Hernangomez - Bo Cruz Queen Latifah - Teresa Sugarman Favorite Scene:   Kermit and Bo line up at center court and Kermit begins the trash talk to get inside of Bo's head, eventually taking him off his game.  Favorite Quote:   "I'll say one last inspirational thing to you: they can't kill you if you're already dead." Review:  Hustle sat on "My List" on my Netflix account for quite a long time. Parked on the couch in the middle of the night with a newborn, and jonesing for some hoops, I dove in on what I read (and heard from others) was a "really good film". I'll give away the suspense, I thought Hustle was decent. It felt too cliche and had little depth, but still, a really good film.  The