Skip to main content

All Eyes Now On Carmelo

Credit: Ben Solomon; New York Times

So here we go again.

Another year. Another dilemma. More reasons to rant. 

This time, my beloved New York Knicks have decided to part ways (I know you don't believe D'Antoni resigned) with Mike D'Antoni as their head coach. Following D'Antoni out the Garden door are his close friends and assistant coaches, Dan D'Antoni (his brother) and Phil Weber. 

Now of course, this all follows the recent news this morning of Carmelo Anthony claiming to want a trade, and then pushing for the removal of D'Antoni and his infamous offensive system. 

It is no secret that the Knicks have been playing atrociously as of late. 

And while I in no way am a huge fan of Carmelo Anthony right now (more on him in just a bit), I do feel it was time this team needed a new voice. I liked D'Antoni, and I'm a believer in his system. I've seen it work when players buy into it. For fifty-plus games last year, we witnessed a group of Raymond Felton, Danilo Gallinari, Wilson Chandler, and Amar'e Stoudemire overachieve under it. 

He's made players better, and let's not have short-sighted memory, Linsanity never happens under any other coach.

However, with the pressure now on to win with a loaded roster and a "superstar" that refused to buy in, D'Antoni's job became tougher. Balancing eleven worthy rotational players and a player that refused to let the system work, D'Antoni's job was slipping away daily. 

D'Antoni also contributed with his suspect substituting and very lax attitude on holding players accountable. 

Regardless, D'Antoni put up with a lot during a tough time which included two years of trades for salary cap room, a major trade that shook-up a growing team, two divas in Anthony and Stephon Marbury, and  a never ending revolving door of players in four years. 

D'Antoni is a great coach who I have no doubt will end up on someone's bench in the NBA. 

---

My biggest problem with this situation is of course, the way the New York Knicks organization has handled the story. Whether it  was Melo pushing him out the door, or not, the Knicks absurd anti-media policy in a market that is media heavy is absolutely ridiculous. More specifically, the absolute lame-duck approach that Jim Dolan has taken with prepared statements and unanswered questions in various crisis such as this one.

One of these days Mr. Dolan, you will have to address your fan base. An not just during a introductory press conference.

---

Finally, onto the man that has made Alex Rodriguez's life much easier in New York City and the 800lb gorilla in the Garden, Carmelo Anthony. Is he to blame for all of this? Not entirely. However, he is very much responsible for a large part of it.

Look, I don't believe Anthony should be traded.

[Side blog: All of these "fans" that claim the Knicks should trade Tyson Chandler and Anthony for Dwight Howard need to settle down. I'm always fascinated by the "flavor of the month" on-the-market talent that always seems to dominate the NBA. Settle down, folks. Settle down.]

Anthony is a tremendous player that can definitely help the Knicks reach the potential and goals we all have for them. However, my issue with Anthony lies in the truth that he isn't as great as advertised. In what has become trendy lately in labeling certain players as "superstars", has over-saturated the conversation in regards to any topic involving Anthony.

"Mike, I'm so happy you're our new coach!"

Once again, let me reiterate, Anthony is a great scorer. However, after now seeing him every night and every game, Anthony's game is just that - a great scorer.

What really annoys me about Anthony is his drive. Does he truly want to win? Or is he more interested in getting his points and calling it a night?

Some nights, the answer is yes to the former, and other nights, to the latter.

And on plays like the one against the Chicago Bulls where he did not dive on the floor for a loose ball, solidifies the questioning of his desire.

Carmelo wanted the bright lights of this city. For weeks we heard about D'Antoni's system holding him back and was the cause of his struggles. Now, with D'Antoni out, there are no more excuses. There is no one else to blame.

All eyes are on you, Carmelo.

And it seems that's what you wanted all along. 

Your legacy is now on the line - its make or break time.
Labels:

Recently Read

Quick Ponder: Future Self

We always think,  what would we say  to our  younger self? However,  what would  our younger self say  if they met us, today?
Read more

Knicks Trauma - Ugh Not Again

Well, that was a kick in the stomach.  Coming off a week where the word "catharsis" was used as the description for the euphoria and release of joy from two and a half decades of suffering, Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals against the Indiana Pacers brought about another word - trauma.  Watching the Knicks collapse was the kind of moments that come with these deep runs and moments. NBA Playoff basketball will do that. Yet, this loss - this one - feels about as bad as the 2004 ALCS when the Yankees collapsed in the series to the Boston Red Sox.  That one carries some serious trauma. Luckily, the series isn't over.  Some other quick thoughts from this awful, awful night, New York Knicks Basketball.  - Not to conjure up hyperbole, or even contribute to "hot take" sports reaction culture - but this might have been the worst loss in Knicks franchise history. I cannot think of another in my lifetime, or historically.  - Tyrese Haliburton's "choke"...
Read more

Knicks Back in ECF Causing Catharsis

I've certainly shared my emotions and thoughts regarding the New York Knicks on this site over the years. There have been plenty of those to sort through - most of them are rants. Tonight, the New York Knicks ultimately destroyed the Boston Celtics in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference Semi-Finals, 119-81. I sat on my couch, afraid to allow myself to feel joy until that final buzzer. As a Knicks fan, I've been through too much to allow myself to do anything else, to make any assumption, until it was final. Until it was confirmed. Until something couldn't fall through...the way we're used to.  Once it was final, it was unreal.  The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference Finals. For the first time since 2000.  I was 15 years old the last time that happened. And that was a run with a squad that I consider (still) to be my favorite Knicks team of all-time.  I sat on my couch with all sorts of feelings. My wife was likely trying to understand the moment. My son, exci...
Read more