Skip to main content

Ichiro's 4,000 hits all about "What If"

 

Is Ichiro's 4,000 hits legit? It's been a question floated around by many baseball fans this week as he approached and eventually eclipsed the well..."milestone". Some believe the numbers from Japan shouldn't count, and others simply look at it as a way to celebrate something that has rarely been done in baseball - any professional baseball. You know, because this would involve counting Japan stats as legit. And you can't do that and stuff. Thus goes the debate cycle. 

Look, I don't look at Ichiro's 4,000 hit the same way I would Rose's and Cobb's accomplishments. Quite frankly, I fall onto the side that doesn't recognize the stats from Japan. However, when it comes to Ichiro, there is always a big part of me that loves to romanticize about the idea of what Ichiro's final MLB numbers would have been if he indeed came to the U.S. earlier.

Instead of arguing of legitimacy, I like to look at the feat (is that still too strong of a description?) as a celebration of what Ichiro really has brought to the game of baseball. He's not in the conversation much, but he is one of the best ball players of all-time. Yes, I just said that. And as stated in a previous Pondering 10 list (Current Must Watch Athletes), Ichiro has been one of my favorite athletes to watch.

Feats such as ten straight years of 200+ hits and breaking and currently holding the record for most hits in a season at 262 are just the beginning. The arm. The Speed. The flare. The swing. The cultural influence. Heck, how many players in the history of baseball are known by one name? How many players have their first name on their jersey?

So yes, Ichiro's 4,000 is a bit of an exaggeration and somewhat of a nice marketing ploy of the New York Yankees. But even with all of that said, there is still a small part of me that wants to say, "C'mon! 4,000 hits is 4,000 hits." But the realist in me likely responds with, " but it's not 4,000 hits." Confusing, I know. This is why I understand the argument.

However, the situation does open up a box of discussions regarding statistical purity? If we exclude Japan, should we also exclude the Negro Leagues? And why? And if we do, why are Ty Cobb, Babe Ruth, and others held in such high regard when the talent they faced weren't the absolute best either?

Whatever. Too deep of a discussion for right now. 

Let's talk even playing field and true comparisons. I decided to compare Ichiro and Pete Rose on an even plane between the ages of 27 and 39 for the sake of this post, and for the baseball nerd in me. What you will find is actually quite shocking.

Click to enlarge

It's quite the interesting comparison to say the least. 

Either way, when it comes down to it, Ichiro is a first ballot Hall of Famer, as well as a potential member of the 3,000 hit club. You know, the real 3,000 club. 

But for me, the beauty of Ichiro is always wondering, "What if..." What if he started his career here in the states, what would his true numbers look like? 

Would 4,000 - the real kind - be possible?

Recently Read Posts

A Product of Us: Thoughts on Durant Trade

I said back in July when Kevin Durant rocked the NBA world with his trade request, that he "showed us who he was".  It wasn't a negative comment, but one that encompasses his entire career being a product of our current sport climate - success and focus on legacy. We emphasize the value of a career on rings, and thus, Durant has too. Why wouldn't he?!  Upon waking up and realizing that Durant will don the purple and orange for the Phoenix Suns in what is clearly now a team to watch come the NBA Playoffs, I find myself further pondering if Kevin Durant is the prime result of what we - yes, us! - have done to the modern athlete.  Today, Durant is one of the greatest basketball players I've ever seen. EVER. The dude is rare. He's a seven-foot magician which makes defending him even more difficult based on how damn efficient he is on the basketball court. It's downright poetic and beautiful to watch Durant play. And yes, I'm romanticizing his game. I belie

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 2/19/23

3 Up 1. India's Tap Water Access - This is a rather remarkable story. It's a story that offers humility wrapped in the extraordinary. India's Jal Jeevan Mission provided almost 79 million - 79 MILLION! - households with tap water. Just tap water!  2. Jordan Make-A-Wish Record - MJ is often loved through nostalgia, narrative, and remembrance for being politically neutral - even in giving. MJ these days has made some influential contributions, including this latest $10M donation to the Make-A-Wish foundation.  3. WWE Elimination Chamber - A tremendously entertaining pay-per-view on the road to Wrestlemania. The best storyline in pro wrestling continues to evolve between Sami Zayn and the Bloodline.  3A. City of Montreal - Give it up to the city of Montreal for what made a few nights of pro wrestling an awesome experience. Can we get this city more events?  3 Down 1. Michigan State Shooting - We're broken. Very broken. My thoughts and prayers are with those friends and fam

Sunday Sundown Rundown - 2/5/23

3 Up 1. Beyonce History - The Queen made history at the Grammys with her 32nd (!!) win. The number alone sounds absolutely ridiculous, but after all, it's Beyonce we are discussing here. Congrats to Queen B.  2. Viola Davis - We're going career acknowledgment this weekend and up next is the wonderfully talented, Viola Davis. Davis entered that rarified air in entertainment rounding out her "EGOT" with a Grammy win. Every time you think about an EGOT, it makes you appreciate just how damn talented you must be to be in that conversation.  3. Tom Brady Career - And then there is Brady, who finally called it a career. It's wild to think I was a teenager watching Tom Brady win his first Super Bowl. Congrats to Brady on a remarkable career.  3 Down 1. Florida Higher Ed Proposal - If Florida leadership wasn't doing all sorts of cringy things within the education system, this week we saw proposed bills to eliminate diversity programs and a call to reduce tenure for ed

Dome Pondering Movie Review: Uncorked (2020)

What is it about? Elijah must balance his love and dream to become a master sommelier with his father's expectations to carry on and take charge of the family business.  Who is in it? Mamoudou Athie - Elijah Courtney B. Vance - Louis Niecy Nash - Sylvia Sasha Compere - Tanya Favorite Scene: [spoiler alert]  Following taking the sommelier exam, Elijah is restless in the hotel room. His father knocks on the door, and suddenly plans to spend the night with him. He pours them both a glass of wine, and they play dominoes.  Favorite Quote:  "How do you choose between family and your dream?" "How do you choose between family and your dream?" Review:  I first saw Uncorked on Netflix during the height of the pandemic lockdown when we all had nothing else better to do than watch television. So of course, go figure, after testing positive for COVID this week, your boy felt miserable nothing better to do while dealing with sever symptoms that watch a movie.  The film was as