Skip to main content

DP Review of First Presidential 2012 Debate


The first leg of the presidential debates came and went, and honestly, it left me wanting more from both candidates. As a former College debater, a lover of the art form, and a total geek for political debates, last tonight's debates left me completely underwhelmed and disappointed. 

From the ridiculously phrased questions (You have two minutes to explain why you are different? How does that force debate, or facts?), the poor moderation of the panel, the insanely lack of respect for the code of a timed debate, and the overall poor structure, this debate was a complete and utter disaster. 

With such a poor structure, we received poorly structured arguments, tons of fluff because of the lack of the time limit, and constant pitter-patter that made both candidates look like children instead of the intelligent officials that they are. 

However, the first debate wasn't a total waste, as there were several things we can take away from the first debate.

1. Romney Can Hold His Own - It's well documented about Romney's struggles connecting with the American people leading up to this debate (Romney Lacks Connection With Nation). He has even done damage to himself. However, tonight he managed to let the facts fly, and he did a great job in presenting all of them in an offensive manner. His attack on "Obamacare" and the attack at the President for putting the bill before jobs was a great line and a great move. There was a certain passion exuding from Romney that I haven't seen yet.

2. President Obama Wheels Are Spinning - Besides the fact I kept getting annoyed at Obama for breaking every rule taught on debating and your stance at the podium (much of it imbedded from my Debate coach in college) as he rocked, leaned, and constantly looked over to at his coach, the President was really flat. That's only way to put it. He just seemed off of his game and lacked any substance or punch in any of his arguments. 

Did anyone else notice he barely looked at Romney, whereas Romney seemed to have embraced the challenge head-on by looking him head on while delivering answers?

Body language and posture sometimes say more than words in a debate. 

Where was the classic, charismatic, fiery, energetic guy we all know?

That guy didn't show up, and it was evident as Obama circled on the same arguments of what he was looking to do, rambled on with unfocused answers, and never truly made arguments that placed Romney on the ropes. 

3. Romney Still Struggles Vocabulary - The whole night Romney made blunders that simply would turn on-the-fence voters against him. Constantly, while watching the debate, the tag-team partner and I would look at each other and say, "did he really just say that?" 

The constant use of "my state" instead of Massachusetts. The use of "they" and "them" when referring to the middle class instead of "us" as a nation. The use of the word "poor" several times when discussing lower-income children. He even caught himself once on this one, and tried to correct it.

It's not worth not voting for him, however, if Romney wants to shake loose the reputation of being disconnected and actually caring for the middle and lower class, he needs to use words that won't alienate these demographics. 

4. Obama Missed Opportunities - This sort of rides of off Obama's flat performance, but the President also missed opportunities to really hit Romney with questions that the nation are clearly waiting for. We all know Romney/Ryan have made claims to what they are going to do, but have yet to actually explain it. President Obama did a good job of mentioning that his economic plan to cut the deficit was on the government website, but instead of shifitng the argument over to really lay Romney out to dry on national TV, President Obama continued to push his plan. 

And hello, how about the "47%" comment? That's a gold mine weapon that Obama could have used, and still can in the upcoming debates. Let's hope he doesn't forget it. 

Recently Read

Quick Ponder: Future Self

We always think,  what would we say  to our  younger self? However,  what would  our younger self say  if they met us, today?

Knicks Trauma - Ugh Not Again

Well, that was a kick in the stomach.  Coming off a week where the word "catharsis" was used as the description for the euphoria and release of joy from two and a half decades of suffering, Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals against the Indiana Pacers brought about another word - trauma.  Watching the Knicks collapse was the kind of moments that come with these deep runs and moments. NBA Playoff basketball will do that. Yet, this loss - this one - feels about as bad as the 2004 ALCS when the Yankees collapsed in the series to the Boston Red Sox.  That one carries some serious trauma. Luckily, the series isn't over.  Some other quick thoughts from this awful, awful night, New York Knicks Basketball.  - Not to conjure up hyperbole, or even contribute to "hot take" sports reaction culture - but this might have been the worst loss in Knicks franchise history. I cannot think of another in my lifetime, or historically.  - Tyrese Haliburton's "choke"...

Knicks Back in ECF Causing Catharsis

I've certainly shared my emotions and thoughts regarding the New York Knicks on this site over the years. There have been plenty of those to sort through - most of them are rants. Tonight, the New York Knicks ultimately destroyed the Boston Celtics in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference Semi-Finals, 119-81. I sat on my couch, afraid to allow myself to feel joy until that final buzzer. As a Knicks fan, I've been through too much to allow myself to do anything else, to make any assumption, until it was final. Until it was confirmed. Until something couldn't fall through...the way we're used to.  Once it was final, it was unreal.  The New York Knicks are in the Eastern Conference Finals. For the first time since 2000.  I was 15 years old the last time that happened. And that was a run with a squad that I consider (still) to be my favorite Knicks team of all-time.  I sat on my couch with all sorts of feelings. My wife was likely trying to understand the moment. My son, exci...